How to Reduce Bentonite Consumption in Pellet Plants (and Cut Silica)

How to Reduce Bentonite Consumption in Pellet Plants (and Cut Silica)

Every pellet plant manager knows the trade-off. Bentonite provides green pellets with the strength to pass through the balling disc, travelling grate, and conveyor. But every kilogram of it puts silica and alumina right into the finished pellet, where it cuts iron grade and increases slag in the furnace.

This guide demonstrates how to reduce bentonite consumption in pellet plants without losing pellet strength. You’ll see how much silica the binder really adds, what bentonite properties matter, and seven methods backed by published research and industry trials. So, let’s start with the numbers.

Why Bentonite Dosage Matters So Much

Bentonite is the most common binder utilised in iron ore pelletising. Research at Michigan Technological University by S. K. Kawatra and S. J. Ripke showed that the usual addition rate is on the order of 0.5 to 1.0% of the moist concentrate weight, or about 5 to 10 kg per tonne.

That little share goes a long way. According to a study in Physicochemical Problems of Mineral Processing in 2023, bentonite is mainly composed of silica (about 65%) and alumina (about 20%). Both are acid gangue that the ironmaking process must flux and melt away.

The same study refers to research where, for direct reduction pellets, each 1% addition of acid gangue increases energy use by approximately 30 kWh per tonne of steel. So cutting the binder helps in three ways:

  • Higher iron grade in fired pellet
  • Reduced slag volume and flux demand downstream
  • Lower cost of binder, which is a large running expense for any plant

How Much Silica Does Your Bentonite Add?

There is an easy way of working it out. Bentonite with 60% silica was employed in a Clariant case study for direct reduction pellets. At that grade, each kg of bentonite per tonne of ore added 0.06% silica to the pellet feed.

The table below shows silica load at different dosages, using the same 60% silica figure.

Bentonite dosage (kg per tonne) Dosage as a percentage of feed Silica added to pellet feed
10 1.0% 0.60%
8 0.8% 0.48%
6 0.6% 0.36%
4 0.4% 0.24%
2 0.2% 0.12%

Material selection also depends on the drilling or industrial application. For example, sodium bentonite may behave differently in saline water because dissolved salts can affect its swelling and dispersion properties. To understand this aspect, read CMS Industries’ article: Bentonite for Saltwater Drilling: Does Sodium Bentonite Work in Brine?.

Reducing Bentonite Consumption in Pellet Plants: 7 Proven Methods

Let’s break it down. These methods are best used in combination, and each should be confirmed by plant trials.

1. Choose a Better Bentonite

Bentonite does not always bond with the same strength. Water absorbency, swelling index, colloid percentage, and alkalinity were found to have a strong effect on green pellet quality, according to a Chinese study of 20 bentonites published in Ironmaking and Steelmaking. The sodium bentonite worked best, as it swells more, disperses better, and binds more strongly.

Five common tests for bentonite were reviewed together in a paper published in 2024 in ISIJ International: methylene blue index, water absorption, swell capacity, colloid index, and cation exchange capacity. It found that sodium modification improves most of these properties and helps to reduce consumption.

The stronger the clay, the more work it does per kg. So the first step is to properly compare suppliers on these properties and not just price per tonne.

2. Do Not Trust a Single Lab Test

But here’s the catch. In a paper by Theodore Karidakis on bentonite evaluation, he warns that a bentonite rated “high quality” by standard tests can turn out to be a poor binder and vice versa. Bentonite is a complex of interacting properties. In that work, plate water absorption gave a fairly good prediction of pelletising performance, but the author still emphasises testing with your own concentrate.

Practical lesson: shortlist bentonites on lab data, then run balling trials with your actual ore before you change.

3. Improve Mixing to Build Bentonite Fibres

This is one of the better documented ways to cut dosage. Kawatra and Ripke found that when bentonite is subjected to compressive shear mixing, it develops fibres, which bind the pellet better. The bentonite required for acceptable pellets was halved, from 0.66% to 0.33%, by using mixing methods that promoted fibre formation.

Their work also notes that with this fibre-forming method, bentonites now considered poor quality can perform well. Plants that use simple paddle mixing may have the most to gain from a review of mixer type and intensity.

4. Pre-Treat the Concentrate with HPGR

High-pressure grinding rolls (HPGR, also called high-pressure roll grinding) press the concentrate and alter its surface. According to a study in ISIJ International in 2004, HPGR pre-treatment of magnetite concentrate was found to improve pelletability, help reduce bentonite dosage, and raise the iron grade of pellets. The authors attributed the effect to the mechano-chemical activation of the concentrate.

Finer grinding in ball mills can also give better pelletability, but research shows that grinding energy increases steeply with fineness; thus, it is a costly route on its own.

5. Control Feed Moisture Tightly

Bentonite can absorb a lot of water. A US patent on iron oxide pellet making states that the use of bentonite for pelletising requires a lot of water because bentonite swells, and this can weaken green pellet strength, so extra water should be avoided. Wet filter cake means that operators have to add more binder just to keep the pellet in shape. If you have stable, well-controlled feed moisture, you can run at the lowest dosage that will work.

6. Use Bentonite Enhancers

Small amounts of additives can increase the binding power of each kilogram of bentonite. A recent US patent (No. 12,031,193) describes soda ash-activated bentonite blended with 0.1% sodium hexametaphosphate. In its example, the same green pellet properties as untreated bentonite at double dose were obtained with 50% less binder, from 6 kg down to 3 kg per tonne. Dry strength was reduced with the lower dose.

Results like these come from specific ores and clays, so take them as a reason to test, not as a pledge.

7. Partly Replace Bentonite with an Organic Binder

The organic binders, such as carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), starch and speciality polymers, do not contain silica. Organic binders typically do not supply silica and are used in lower dosages.

The Clariant case demonstrates how this works in a real plant. The plant reduced bentonite from 5 to 6 kg per tonne to 1.5 kg per tonne and added 0.5 kg per tonne of an organic pelletising additive. This was a 70% reduction in bentonite and a 0.21% reduction in silica from the binder.

That has its limits. A thesis at the Middle East Technical University showed that organic binders give good green and dry pellets but often do not give enough strength to preheated and fired pellets because they burn out and leave no slag bond. Therefore, most plants use them in conjunction with a reduced dose of bentonite rather than as a total substitute.

Comparing the Methods

Method Typical effect on bentonite dose Capital need Main watchout
Better bentonite selection Moderate cut Low Needs plant trials
Intensive or shear mixing Up to half in research Medium Mixer change or upgrade
HPGR pre-treatment Moderate cut, plus higher Fe grade High Large equipment cost
Moisture control Small to moderate cut Low to medium Filter performance
Enhancers (e.g., SHMP) Up to half in patent examples Low Dry strength may drop.
Organic binder blend Up to 70% in case study Low to medium Fired strength, dust

A Step-by-Step Plan for Your Plant

Next: use this sequence to cut the binder and avoid production risk.

  • Benchmark today’s dosage in kg/tonne and the silica and alumina it adds.
  • Test your current bentonite lot by lot for swelling index, methylene blue index, water absorption, and moisture.
  • Identify two or three alternative grades with better lab results.
  • Do balling trials with your own concentrate and measure the drop number, wet and dry compressive strength, and moisture.
  • Before adding new chemicals, review your mixer and moisture control.
  • Trial boosters or organic mixtures at minor reductions in bentonite dosage.

A Quick Savings Example

Track the results monthly to keep savings as ore and clay supplies change.

Quick Savings Example

Here’s how the numbers add up. Assume a plant producing 4 million tonnes of pellets per year and using 8 kg bentonite per tonne. It uses around 32,000 tonnes of bentonite per year. 8,000 tonnes a year are saved by reducing the dose to 6 kg/tonne. The same cut with a 60% silica bentonite removes about 0.12% silica from the pellet feed. Size the price to your own plant numbers.

Sourcing Pelletising Bentonite from India

Gujarat’s Kutch district is a major source of sodium bentonite for iron ore pelletising in India. CMS Industries, based in Mandvi Taluka, Kutch, is an ISO 9001:2015 certified bentonite miner and processor with two iron ore pelletising grades, CMS IOP 650 and CMS IOP 700. The company says its pelletising bentonite has a higher montmorillonite content, allowing lower addition rates. Verify swelling, methylene blue, and water absorption data with CMS Industries since they do not publish test values on their website. Run balling trials with your concentrate before switching.

Final Word

“Bentonite will remain the backbone binder for most pellet plants, but few plants are running it at the lowest dose they could. Start with a better, well-tested clay. Then improve mixing, stabilise feed moisture, and trial enhancers or organic blends in small increments. Every kg saved per tonne reduces cost and takes silica out of the pellet.” Measure twice, and the savings will be seen in the binder bill and the blast furnace or DRI module.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How much bentonite is used in iron ore pelletising?

Most plants use bentonite at about 0.5 to 1.0% by weight of the moist concentrate, or about 5 to 10 kg/t. The correct dose depends on ore fineness, moisture, mixing, and bentonite quality, so plants should confirm this by balling trials.

2. How much silica does bentonite add to pellets?

It is determined by the silica content of the bentonite. Each kg/t of 60% silica bentonite adds approx. 0.06% silica to the pellet feed. That’s roughly 0.48% added silica, at 8 kg per tonne.

3. Can organic binders fully replace bentonite?

Not usually. Organic binders provide good green and dry strength and contain no silica. They burn out in firing, usually producing weaker preheated and fired pellets. Most plants use them to replace some of the bentonite, but not all of the bentonite is replaced by them.

4. Which bentonite properties matter most for pelletising?

Swelling index, water absorption, methylene blue index, colloid percentage, and montmorillonite content affect binding. Sodium bentonite is usually the best. Lab tests can be misleading, so confirm any grade by doing trials with your own concentrate.

5. Does better mixing really reduce bentonite consumption?

Yes. Research at Michigan Tech showed that bentonite, aided by compressive shear mixing, forms fibres that improve pellet binding efficiency, allowing the dose to be reduced from 0.66% to 0.33%. Suppliers such as CMS Industries can share data to help enable such trials.

 

error: Content is protected !!